Drowning in voices
13 January 2004
Yesterday I had a bit of free time and went a bit comment crazy on other people's sites. But not as crazy as I could have.
Sometimes when I'm reading an article and feel moved to respond I'll scroll down to the comments area to have a look at what other people have ruminated over, only to discover that *horror* there's 75 comments. It's usually at this stage that I proceed to the next site on my favourites list, unless the topic is one that I'm really, really, really interested in i.e. me.
Comments are a great idea and to me they represent the next evolution in journalism/correspondence – not only do they allow an author to express their views, but those views can also be discussed, adding innumerably to the ideas contained in the original piece. However, when you visit a popular site sometimes a discussion is no longer a discussion, but peak hour on the subway; a disorganised mass of thoughts and arguments. Sure, there may be some valid and extremely strong points raised in the discussion, but the sheer volume of them swamps my brain and makes my eyes glaze over. (Ever try reading a Slashdot discussion?)
It's no reflection on the sites themselves – they should be lauded for the attention they receive and the superb content which draws that attention – they are merely victims of their own success. For instance, Dave Shea's post on a page-based CMS garnered 61 comments in less than three days. Damned if I'm going to read 5,000 words of comments.
On more technical articles such as that posted by Dave S, I generally try not to comment unless I have something I feel is important to add to the discussion, and which has not been touched on previously. I try to avoid the "me too" post which adds nothing to the discussion except the commentator's name, and the "bitch" post whinging about pedantic errors in other people's posts.
Of course, I might just have the attention span of a dragonfly and you all might enjoy scrolling 523 lines.
Follow me on Twitter
To hear smaller but more regular stuff from me, follow @themaninblue.
- Resolution dependent layout update
- footerStickAlt: A more robust method of positioning a footer
- widgEditor: A simple, standards-compliant WYSIWYG HTML editor
- Accessible, stylish form layout